DAILY FROM: AHMEDABAD, CHANDIGARH, DELHI, JAIPUR, KOLKATA, LUCKNOW, MUMBAI, NAGPUR, PUNE, VADODARA JOURNALISM OF COURAGE FRIDAY, DECEMBER 28, 2018, JAIPUR, LATE CITY, 16 PAGES `5.00 WWW.INDIANEXPRESS.COM SINCE 1932 MUSLIM WOMEN (PROTECTION OF RIGHTS ON MARRIAGE) BILL Triple Talaq Bill passed in LS, Opp says provisions unconstitutional Will ensure justice for Muslim women, says govt; seeks to criminalise civil wrong, says Opp EXPRESS NEWS SERVICE EXPRESS NETWORK PORTFOLIO ALLOCATION GEHLOTKEEPS HOME,FINANCE PAGE 4 PM hits back: Chowkidar won’t spare thieves Modi in Dharamshala on Thursday. Kamleshwar Singh VARINDER BHATIA DHARAMSHALA, DEC 27 DAYS AFTER Shiv Sena chief UddhavThackerayborrowedthe Congress’s “chowkidar-chor-hai” phrase to target him, Prime MinisterNarendraModihitback on Thursday, warning that the chowkidar would not spare the thieves. Addressing a rally here to mark the first anniversary of the Jai Ram Thakur-led BJP governmentinHimachalPradesh,Modi said: “Unko chowkidar se dar lagne laga hai. Choron ki neend haram ho gayi hai, ke chowkidar sone ko tayyar nahi hai, chowkidarchoronkochhodnekeliyetayyar nahi hai. Isliye pareshaani hai (They have started to be afraid of the watchman. The thieves have lost their sleep, because the watchman is not ready to sleep, the watchman is not ready to spare the thieves. That’s why they are disturbed).” Mentioningthescamsunder the Congress-ruled governments, he said: “Whatever wrong has been happening in the country, the loot that happened, the exchequer was used for personal consumption... I launched a crusade against it. And, with your blessings, I will not stop this fight.” Earlier this week, addressing a rally in Pandharpur, Thackeray had taken potshots at Modi by borrowing, for the first time, the “chowkidar-chor-hai” phrase often invoked by the Congress. Recounting a meeting in Beed with a farmer who showed him a lime tree — normally used to keep off pests — itself getting infested, he said: “I told him, ‘Halli paharekarichchoryakaraylaalaagale aahet (Today, security persons have themselves become thieves).” Paharekari is the Marathi word for chowkidar or security person. INSIDE NEW DELHI, DECEMBER 27 AMIDHEATEDprotestsfromthe Opposition,includingawalkout, andadetermineddefencebythe government, the amended TripleTalaqBill,whichmandates imprisonment for violators, was passed in the Lok Sabha Thursday. While the Opposition described provisions in the Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Marriage) Bill as “unconstitutional” and demanded that it be referred to a select committee, the government argued that the legislation aimed to empower and ensure justice for Muslim women. Law Minister Ravi Shankar Prasad, who brought the amended Bill that seeks imprisonment for Muslim men who resort to the practice of instant divorce, asked the Opposition not to weigh it “on the scales of politics”asitwasabout“humanity and justice”. Prasad also rejected the Opposition’s demand to send thelegislationtoaParliamentary panel,sayingmostof thesuggestions from MPs were incorporated in the amended Bill. However, echoing the Mufti Suhail and his wife moved to this house in Amroha about a month ago. Gajendra Yadav RELATEDREPORT,PAGE5 Billsetto facehurdle inRajya Sabha Law Minister Ravi Shankar Prasad after the Bill was passed, on Thursday. Anil Sharma OPP’S OBJECTIONS ■ Can’t criminalise civil wrong ■ No need for separate law after SC order ■ Violates Constitutional rights of faith, belief ■ Personal laws protected under Article 25 ■ Why such a law only for Muslims? ■ Gender justice not motive but politics Bulandshahr: Delhi cab driver arrested for killing Inspector EXPRESS NEWS SERVICE NOIDA, DECEMBER 27 THREE WEEKS after naming BajrangDalactivistYogeshRajas the prime suspect in the killing of Inspector Subodh Kumar Singh in mob violence on December 3 in Bulandshahr, the Uttar Pradesh police Thursday arrested a Delhi taxi driver, Prashant Natt, for the crime. Police said Raj — who is on therun—isstillanaccusedinthe case and that Natt (30), who was not named in the FIR registered, was arrested after he was seen in videos of the incident, which was corroborated with testi- Inspector Subodh Singh was killed on Dec 3 monies of other accused and technical evidence. Inspector Singh and a local Sumit Kumar were killed on December 3 in mob violence near Siyana village during protests against alleged cow slaughter. Accordingtothepolice,Singh fired at a growing crowd near Siyana village in self-defence CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 AHMEDABAD, DECEMBER 27 FOR THE first time since 2013, business delegations from Pakistanwillbeattendingthebiennial Vibrant Gujarat Global Summit scheduled to be held this time from January 18-20, 2019, the organisers confirmed. According to records reviewedbyTheIndianExpress,at leastseven delegationsfromdifferentregionsof Pakistanareexpectedtotakepart,makingitthe largest contingent ever from the country at the summit. They are among the 52 delegations representing commerce and trade bodies from various countries who have confirmed PAGE 1 ANCHOR their participation for the Global Conclave of International Chambers, which is one of the events at the summit. In 2013, a delegation from the Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry had arrived for the summit and attended a pre-event buyer-seller meet on January 9-10. However, with bilateral tensions rising following the killing of two Indian soldiers in a ceasefire violation at the Mendhar sector of J&K’s PoonchonJanuary8,thedelegation left without attending the main summit on January 12-13. At the time, the state government cited visa clearances as a reasonfortheearlydepartureand said that most members had visas only for Ahmedabad while TIGER MAULS WOMAN IN RANTHAMBORE PAGE 4 THE EDITORIAL PAGE SAFETYNETOF THEFUTURE BY PRANAB BARDHAN PAGE 8 WORLD IN IRAQ, TRUMP SAYS U.S. CAN’T CONTINUE TO BE POLICEMAN P 13 the main event was held in Gandhinagar. Since then, two summits have gone by without anyrepresentationfromPakistan. When contacted, state governmentofficialsrefusedtocomment on the issue. But official documents show that Pakistan will be represented by two delegationsfromFaisalabad,andone each from Islamabad, Peshawar, Karachi, Punjab province and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. D Thara, vice-chairperson and managing director of Gujarat Industrial Development Corporation (GIDC), told reporters that Pakistan was one of the countries from where representatives of trade chambers have been invited. CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 triple talaq can only be filed by the victim (wife) or her blood relations, and that a magistrate cangrantbailwithcertainterms and conditions. OnThursday,Prasadalsosaid that the Bill has made the offence compoundable, meaning that the case can be withdrawn if themanandhisestrangedwife reach a compromise. He said the Parliament had unanimously supported laws aimed at giving CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 FULL COVERAGE THE LATEST version of the Triple Talaq Bill will supersede an earlier draft passed in Lok Sabha and pending in the Rajya Sabha. The amended Bill now needs to be passed by Parliament within 42 days. However, the Bill is expected to face resistance in the Rajya Sabha where the ruling dispensation does not enjoy a majority, and with AIADMK MPs signalling their opposition by joining a walkout. PAGE 7 Stung on tape, UP Govt orders graft probe in 3 Ministries EXPRESS NEWS SERVICE LUCKNOW, DECEMBER 27 UP CHIEF Minister Yogi Adityanath has ordered the suspensionof threestatesecretariat employees working as personal secretaries to his government’s ministersaftertheywereshown asking for bribes in exchange for contracts and official postings in apurportedstingoperationconducted by ABP News channel. The purported sting shows the personal secretaries of Minister for Backward Class Welfare Om Prakash Rajbhar, Minister of State for Mining, Excise and Prohibition Archana Pandey, and Minister of State for Basic, Secondary and Higher Education Sandeep Singh allegedly negotiating deals linked to the mining and education departments. A statement issued by the Chief Minister’s Office said he has also ordered FIRs to be filed againstthethreeemployeesand the formation of a Special InvestigatingTeam(SIT)toinvestigate the incident. The SIT, under ADG (Lucknow Zone) Rajiv Krishna, has been asked to immediately begin its probe and submit a report within 10 days, it said. “The Chief Minister has said CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 NEW DELHI, DECEMBER 27 A PULITZER Prize-winning journalist, working as Chief Photographer with global news agencyReutersatitsDelhioffice, has been denied entry back into India for alleged violation of visa conditions. CathalMacNaughtonandhis colleagues were awarded the Pulitzer Prize in May 2018 for theirphotographsthat“exposed the world to the violence Rohingya refugees faced in fleeing Myanmar”. When contacted, officials in the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) said that MacNaughton DEEPTIMAN TIWARY AMROHA, HAPUR, DEC 27 A WEEK before Christmas, men claimingtobemunicipalsurveyors, fanned out across the Mullano Mohalla colony and neighbouring areas in Amroha towninUttarPradesh.Theytook photographs of certain houses even as the local councillor said no such survey was commissioned. Early on December 26, a team of NIA officers along with local police raided one of the houses ‘surveyed’ in Mullano Mohalla and arrested Mufti Suhail, the alleged mastermind of an Islamic State module. In a similar raid at the adjacent Qazi Zadacolony,theagencyarrested Suhail’s alleged associate, MohammadIrshad,anautorickshaw driver. AccordingtotheNIA,thetwo were arrested with eight others fromAmroha,HapurandDelhi’s Seelampur for allegedly being part of a self-appointed group called the Harkat-ul-Harb-eIslam and affiliated to Islamic State. The NIA has claimed that the arrests stopped the group from carrying out a series of terrorattacksandsaidtheyhaverecovered a huge cache of arms and explosives and even a rudimentary rocket launcher. Suhail’s relatives and neighbours in Amroha say they barely knew him since he moved to the UP town a little more than a month ago. His house, a one room-kitchen unit which is part of a joint family’s property, is at the end of the labyrinthine Moullan Mohalla. Only his uncle’s family lives in Amroha after Suhail’s father moved to Delhi’s Jaffarabad almost 40 years ago. Suhail’s cousin Mohammed Yahya, a sales tax officer, says, “The family came here once in a year or two if there was a weddingorif someonedied.Wehave hardlybeenintouch.Forthepast month or so, Suhail has been CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 This time in Bangla poll heat, why India not hot-button issue EXPRESSINDHAKA SHUBHAJIT ROY Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist denied entry back into India RAHUL TRIPATHI Not rocket launcher but a hydraulic jack used in trolleys: kin of accused DECEMBER 27 Govt says Cathal MacNaughton violated visa rules “violatedvisaconditionsbytravellingtorestrictedandprotected areas in Jammu and Kashmir without permission”. Sources told The Indian ExpressthatwhenMacNaughton wassentbackfromDelhiairport — he was returning from an overseas trip — he had a “valid visa” to enter India. MacNaughton’s timeline on Instagram shows he was in CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 WITH THE election campaign duetoendonFridaymorning,48 hours before Bangladesh goes to polls on Sunday, the India factor —whichhasbeenpartofthepreelection rhetoric in the past — is missingfromcampaignspeeches. WhathashelpedisthatIndia hasnotissuedanystatement,except for asking for “free and fair elections”, unlike many of its western counterparts — especially the Americans and Europeans. “It’s very interesting to see that India did not get mentioned at all by the two prominent political parties during their election campaign,” an Indian diplomat in Dhaka told The Indian Express. There was some antiIndia mention by one of the Islamist fringe groups, Hizbut Tahrir, but none of the leaders from either the BNP or Awami League talked up anti-India sen- An Awami League supporter in Dhaka on Thursday. AP timents during the campaign. In the past elections, the BangladeshNationalistParty,led by Khaleda Zia, who is in jail on corruption charges, would accuse the ruling Awami League, led by Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina, of being “pro-India”. “I think they realised that the BNPwasnotbenefittingbyalienating India,” the diplomat said. Sabihuddin, a former diplomatandforeignaffairsadvisorto Khaleda Zia, told The Indian Express:“Indiaisnotafactorhere thistime.Weshouldnotbebothered whether BJP or Congress is in power in Delhi. Similarly, the Indian government should not bother whether Awami League or the BNP wins the elections.” CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 Mining Ban, Moving Allowed, In Between The Tragedy Since ’14 ban, NGT teams report illegal mining in Meghalaya, local officials say no way to check if coal is old or new INDIA OFFERS VISA, BUT KARMAPA YET TO RESPOND PAGE 5 Opposition’s objections, Leader of Congress in the House, Mallikarjun Kharge, demanded thatitbereferredtoajointselect committeeof thetwoHousesfor greaterscrutiny.TheOpposition, and MPs of the AIADMK, also staged a walkout protesting against the government’s decision not to refer the Bill to a select committee. In August, the government hadbroughtamendmentstothe Bill after conceding to some of the Opposition’s demands to ringfence the proposed law against misuse. It cleared provisions that complaints in cases of First time after 2013 freeze, Pak gets space at Gujarat summit AVINASH NAIR Before IS arrests, officials surveyed Amroha homes ABHISHEK SAHA KHLIEHRIAT (MEGHALAYA), DECEMBER 27 TRAVELLING TO reach the flooded coal mine on a remote hillock in Meghalaya’s East Jaintia Hills district where at least 15 workers are trapped for 15 days now and feared dead, you need to take a left from the mainroadnearthepolicestation at district headquarters Khliehriat. On the two-hour-long journey on that route to reach the site, Ksan, both sides of the road are dotted with so many heaps of coal you lose count. At several deposits,theheapsareuploaded into waiting trucks, to be sent off BUSINESS AS USUAL BY UNNY Coal piled up along the road leading to the mine. Abhishek Saha to a destination in neighbouring Assam or beyond. For anyone travelling through the area for the first time, the sight of such large coal depositsandtrucksbeingloaded with coal might come as a jolt considering that the National Green Tribunal (NGT) had in 2014 banned “illegal” mining of coal (especially mentioning the popular rat-hole technique) in the state. But the reason one sees so many coal-laden trucks on the roads of Meghalaya is because, in at least seven consequent or- Jaipur ders, the NGT and then the Supreme Court, hearing petitions by coal-mine owners, allowed the transportation of coal mined prior to the implementation of the ban on April 17, 2014. And as per the latest SC order dated December 4, transportation of coal mined prior to the ban was extended to January 31, 2019. CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 COAL INDIA: WE HAVE REQUISITIONED PUMPS PAGE 5
Indian Express Limited is an Indian news media publishing company. It publishes several widely circulated dailies, including The Indian Express and The Financial Express in English, the Loksatta in Marathi and the Jansatta in Hindi.