DAILY FROM: AHMEDABAD, CHANDIGARH, DELHI, JAIPUR, KOLKATA, LUCKNOW, MUMBAI, NAGPUR, PUNE, VADODARA PAGES 6 & 5 SUV driven by Cong leader runs amok on busy Jaipur street, 3 killed PARUL KULSHRESTHA JAIPUR, APRIL 8 AN SUV allegedly ploughed through abusy street inJaipuron Monday night, killing three peopleandinjuringatleastsixothers. According to police, around 10 pm, Usmaan Khan (62), a factory owner and a Congress leader, was driving his vehicle in the Walled City area, the lanes of which are typically congested. Police are probing if he was under the influence of alcohol. Following the incident, the Jaipur district Congress committeesubmittedamemorandumto Jaipur Collector Jitendra Soni, whichstated:“Itwaslearntfrom the newspapers that Usman Khan,thevice-presidentofJaipur CityDistrictCongressCommittee, ran over several people while drivingrecklessly,inwhichthree people died and many were injured. Therefore, Jaipur City DistrictCongressCommitteedemands from the state government that proper compensation be given to the dead and injured and the culprit be given the harshest punishment.” The incident took place underthejurisdictionof Nahargarh police station. SHO Rameshwari said, “The driver was caught while trying to escape… We detained him and conducted a medical examination. An investigationisunderwayandwewill take action accordingly.” Police said the accused hit several vehicles, including twowheelers, over a 500-metre distance. He first hit a scooter near Santoshi Mata temple. Around 10.30 am on Tuesday, BJP MLA from Hawa Mahal, Balmukund Acharya, led a protest in front of the police station, demanding compensation for families of those dead. `6.00 WWW.INDIANEXPRESS.COM SINCE 1932 LAYS DOWN TIMELINE FOR RAJ BHAVAN DECISION ON BILLS ‘Illegal’: SC sets aside TN Governor’s act of withholding assent to Bills Why ruling stands out: Sparingly used powers invoked, strong message sent Kerala says ruling applies to its plea as well, hearing next month ANANTHAKRISHNAN G NEW DELHI, APRIL 8 IN A decision with significant ramifications, the Supreme CourtTuesdaydeclaredasillegal and erroneous the action of TamilNaduGovernorR NRaviin reserving 10 Bills for consideration of the President in November 2023 after they had already been reconsidered by the state Assembly. The bench of Justices J B Pardiwala and R Mahadevan ruled that any subsequent steps taken by the President, too, do not survive. It also laid down a timeline for Governors to decide on Bills presented to them. Exercising powers under Article 142 of the Constitution, the bench also declared the CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 Governor R N Ravi; Chief Minister M K Stalin BUSINESS AS USUAL BY UNNY APURVA VISHWANATH NEW DELHI, APRIL 8 BYEXERCISINGitsextraordinary powers to virtually grant assent to10Billsthatwerependingwith Tamil Nadu Governor R N Ravi, the Supreme Court sent a strong signalTuesday,expressingitsdis- E pleasure with the actions of the Raj Bhavan. The bench of Justices J B Pardiwala and R Mahadevan invoked Article 142 to take over the role vested with the Governor in the lawmakingprocess.Theextraordinarypowertopassorderstodo EXPLAINED GRENADE BLAST AT HOUSE OF PUNJAB BJP LEADER, 2 HELD WAQF ACT COMES INTO FORCE, SC MAY HEAR PLEAS APRIL 15 POSTAL REGN. NO. JAIPUR CITY/001/2024-26 JOURNALISM OF COURAGE WEDNESDAY, APRIL 9, 2025, JAIPUR, LATE CITY, 18 PAGES EXPRESS NETWORK ● “complete justice” is sparingly used by the Court, especially when itinvolvesotherConstitutional authorities. ● The Court has also redrawn the contours of theGovernor’spowersbyprescribing a one-month time limit CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 Historic, victory for states: TN; Kerala says Governors should heed ‘warning’ ARUN JANARDHANAN & SHAJU PHILIP LAW GOVERNOR’SPOWERS EXPLAINED, PAGE 13 CHENNAI, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, APRIL 8 OPPOSITION PARTIES joined the DMK Tuesday in welcoming the Supreme Court verdict holding that prolonged inaction of Governors on Bills passed by the state Assembly was erroneous and illegal. Momentsaftertheapexcourt pronounced its order on its petition against Governor R N Ravi, Tamil Nadu Chief Minister and DMK chief M K Stalin told the Assembly: “A few moments ago, our government received a historicjudgmentfromtheSupreme Court… This order is not only for TamilNadu,buta hugevictoryfor all the states in India.” He also called it a vindication of federalism, the autonomy of states and Dravidian politics. “The fight for state autonomy CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 CM Pinarayi’s daughter set to face money laundering probe by ED T Veena, daughter of CM Pinarayi Vijayan DEEPTIMAN TIWARY NEW DELHI, APRIL 8 IN CONVERSATION WITH CHIRAG PASWAN Union Food Processing Industries Minister and LJP (Ram Vilas) president Chirag Paswan with Anant Goenka, Executive Director, The Indian Express Group, and Vandita Mishra, National Opinion Editor, The Indian Express, at the Express Adda event in New Delhi on Tuesday. Abhinav Saha ‘Fake doctor’ held, real TMC infighting out in open: Kalyan Dr Camm from UK says targets woman MP, Kirti, Saugata con goes back 5 years ATRI MITRA & ASAD REHMAN ANAND MOHAN J KOLKATA, NEW DELHI, APRIL 8 YEARS AFTER a Twitter account impersonating him and posting oncontentiouspoliticalissuesdisappeared, Dr John Camm, a UKbased cardiologist and professor ofclinicalcardiologyatStGeorge’s UniversityofLondon,thoughtthe worst was behind him. Though the Twitter account was taken down, the impersonatorhasnowlandedinthepolice net as cops in Madhya Pradesh THE TRINAMOOL Congress (TMC)findsitself inthemiddleof a political crisis after a spat between its Lok Sabha chief whip Kalyan Banerjee and other MPs escalated on Tuesday. A woman MP who recently had an argumentwithBanerjeeinpublichas written to party chief and West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee,complainingabouthim. At the heart of the row is an altercation between Banerjee BHOPAL, APRIL 8 UK-based cardiologist Dr John Camm (left); his impersonator begintheirprobeintothepastof “Dr Narendra John Camm”, who CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 TMC Lok Sabha chief whip Kalyan Banerjee and the woman MP that occurred on the premises of the Election Commission (EC) office in Delhi on April 4 when a delegationof TMCMPswentthereto submit a memorandum, party insiders said. ATMCMPsaidtheargument began after the woman MP realised her name was missing fromthelistofsignatories.“There were two things. First, we were told to meet at the TMC office in Parliament. Our party’s chief whip, Kalyan Banerjee, skipped thatmeetingandreachedtheEC office. This annoyed some of us. When we went there, the name of one woman MP was missing, and instead Kakoli Ghosh Dastidar’snamehadbeenadded. Dastidarwasnottheretosubmit thememorandum.Thisannoyed the woman MP who asked Banerjee why her name was not added. This caused the spat. At that moment, Banerjee used CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 IN FURTHER trouble for Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan’s daughter, T Veena, the EnforcementDirectorate(ED)islearntto bepreparingtoregisteramoney laundering case against her. Veena has been under the scanner of various central government agencies following an Income Tax case dating back to 2023, according to which her now-defunct information technology firm, Exalogic Solutions Private Limited, received “illegal payment” of Rs 1.72 crore from CochinMineralsandRutileLimited (CMRL) in 2018-2019, although it had not provided any service. Subsequently, the Serious FraudInvestigationOffice(SFIO), under the Ministry of Corporate Affairs, also launched a probe against Veena’s firm. Earlier, the Karnataka High Court rejected a petition filed by Exalogic SolutionschallengingtheSFIOprobe. Last week, the Union Ministry of Corporate Affairs approvedprosecutionproceedings against Veena following a chargesheetfiledbytheSFIOina Kochi court. “We have written to SFIO seeking case papers in the matter. The charges slapped by SFIO in its chargesheet fall under CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 BOOSTING TIES Prime Minister Narendra Modi meets visiting Dubai Crown Prince and UAE Deputy PM Sheikh Hamdan bin Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum in New Delhi on Tuesday. PTI PAGE7 RECIPROCAL TARIFFS FROM TODAY US buyers seek price cuts, freeze orders, exporters turn to Centre for relief RAVI DUTTA MISHRA NEW DELHI, APRIL 8 WITHUSbuyerspushingfordiscounts and, in most cases, placing orders on hold following President Donald Trump’s announcementof reciprocaltariffs, Indian exporters are learnt to have approached the government for relief, seeking additional fund allocations, lower interest rates on loans, and expansionof exportcreditinsurance to cover even pending deliveries, in a bid to retain their foothold in the US market. While the 10 per cent baseline tariffs for all countries came into effect from April 5, the 26 per cent reciprocal tariffs imposed on India kick in on Wednesday. Indicating that lower reciprocal tariffs may not be an absolute advantage, exporters ex- GOVT & POLITICS CONG TARGETS GOVT ON U.S. TARIFFS: CLOSE TIES YES, BUT THIS WILL HURT PAGE 7 pressed concern about emerging competitors — such as Kenya for tea exports, Japan and South Koreaformachinery,Ecuadorfor marine products and Turkey for apparel — who may gain ground due to a duty advantage in the US market. These countries arenottraditionalrivals,butmay CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 US slaps 104% tariff on China, says willing to talk to other countries SUSAN HEAVEY, TREVOR HUNNICUTT & JOE CASH WASHINGTON, BEIJING, APRIL 8 THE UNITED States said on Tuesday that 104% duties on imports from China will take effect shortly after midnight, even as the Trump administration movedtoquicklystarttalkswith other trading partners targeted by President Donald Trump's sweeping tariff plan. US stocks retreated on the news. Global markets had previously posted gains on hopes that Trump might be willing to negotiate down the array of country andproduct-specifictradebarriers he is erecting around the world'slargestconsumermarket. The administration has scheduled talks with South Korea and Japan, two close allies and major trading partners, and Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni is due to visit next week. But the White House made clearthatcountry-specifictariffs of up to 50% would nevertheless take effect at 12:01 am Eastern Time (0401 GMT), as planned. Those tariffs will be especially steep for China, as Trump has ratcheted up duties on its imports to 104% in response to counter-tariffs Beijing announcedlastweek.Chinahasrefused to bow to what it called “blackmail” and has vowed to “fight to the end”. Administration officials said theywouldnotprioritisenegotiations with the world's No. 2 CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 No body, murder weapon, how cop was convicted in missing woman’s killing PAGE 1 ANCHOR MOHAMED THAVER & SADAF MODAK MUMBAI, APRIL 8 IT IS a question that Raju Gore, 53,hasansweredmultipletimes over nine years since his estranged wife, Assistant Police Inspector(API)AshwiniBidre,37, waslastseenaliveoutsideaNavi Mumbai police station on April 11, 2016. “TheywonderwhyIpursued the case despite our estrange- ment. We may have been estranged,butitisnotasif Ashwini did not have someone to seek justice for her. Also, we have a daughter together. I needed an answer in case she asked me what happened to her mother,” says Raju, a farmer and former Maharashtra Navnirman Sena activist. On April 5 this year, a Panvel court convicted Ashwini’s senior, former police inspector Abhay Kurundkar, 61, and two others of her murder in April 2016. The quantum of sentence forAbhay,whowasinarelationship with Ashwini, and the others will be pronounced on April 11—exactlynineyearstotheday Ashwini was last seen alive. According to court records, Abhay murdered Ashwini at his Thane residence on April 11, 2016, during a suspected fight over her demand that they get married. Abhay is married and has two children. Abhay, with help from his driver and a friend — the other convicts — allegedly dismembered her body and dumped it at Bhayander Creek, around 20 kmfromhishouse.Todestroyall traces of Ashwini’s DNA, he allegedly even got his car and house repainted, according to police and court documents. Abhay Kurundkar (left) was convicted of killing Ashwini Bidre (above) What makes the conviction inthecasestandoutisthatinthe absence of a body and with Ashwini'smobilephoneandthe murderweaponyettobetraced, policeandtheprosecutionrelied on circumstantial evidence to prove that Abhay had murdered Ashwiniandtheco-accusedhad helpedhimdestroytheevidence. According to court records, Ashwini lived alone on rent in Navi Mumbai at the time of her disappearance. A few weeks before she was last seen alive, she had applied for a 10-day leave to attend a Vipassana session in Igatpuri, Nashik. When she failed to report for work after 10 days, her colleagues didn’t think much of it “since she had been stressed for monthsandwashavingrelationshipproblems”.OnJune14,2016, twomonthslater,herfamilyfiled amissingpersoncomplaintwith the Navi Mumbai police. Her estranged husband Raju says the Navi Mumbai police Jaipur made “no effort” to investigate the case, prompting him to approach the Bombay High Court. “The court directed the commissioner to form a team of senior officers. Assistant Commissioner of Police Sangeeta Alphonsostartedmakingaheadway in the case, but was transferred. By October 2016, Abhay, whowasonleavesinceFebruary 2016,wasbackonduty,”hesays. As public pressure mounted, the case was raised in the Maharashtra Assembly and in December 2016, Abhay was arrested. Despite the initial progress, Raju says, the probe came to a standstill. In 2018, he launched a campaign to seek justice for Ashwini – from meeting Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis to making representations to then Chief Justice of India (CJI) and then President Ram Nath Kovind. “In my letters to the CJI and the President, I sought permission to die since the probe had stalled. They wrote to the MaharashtraChief Secretaryand ACP Alphonso was brought back andaskedtooversee thecase for three months,” Raju says. Days after ACP Alphonso took charge, Abhay’s driver Kundan Bhandari and his friend CONTINUED ON PAGE 2