The editorial Page: Babasaheb and Bapu are now friends, and for all of us, that is a reason for hope 10 TUESdAY, NovEMBER 17, 2026 Journalism of Courage KOlKAtA, lAtE CIty, 16 PAGES ₹6.00 (₹12 in north East states, ₹20 in Andaman) l www.indianexpress.com dA I ly f R O m : A h m E dA B A d , C h A n d I GA R h , d E l h I , j A I P U R , KO l K AtA , l U C K n O w , m U m B A I , n AG P U R , PAt n A , P U n E , vA d O dA R A happening today lSC will hear a batch of petitions filed by Rahul Gandhi and other Opposition leaders, challenging the functioning of CEC Gyanesh Kumar and the SIR. leleCtion CommiSSion will release the draft electoral roll for Uttar Pradesh as part of the special summary revision. Track These and more on www.indianexpress.com the world PAge 12 roBert PAttinSon iS new JAmeS Bond on SiDelineS of aSean, eaSt aSia SUmmitS in manila Quad leaders meet today, signal to China before talks with US, Russia Ties with ASEAN at heart of India’s Act East Policy: PM Shubhajit roy New Delhi, November 16 the LeADeRS of the Quad grouping — Prime Minister narendra Modi, US President Donald trump, Japanese Prime Minister Sanae takaichi and Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese — are set to meet in Manila on tuesday, on the sidelines of the ASeAn and east Asia summits. this will be trump's first Quad leaders' meeting since beginning his second term in January 2025. “On tuesday evening in Manila, the President will participate in a multilateral meeting with Quad leaders to discuss shared interests of peace, prosperity and security in the Indo-Pacific region,” Olivia Wales, Assistant Press Secretary at the White house, said in Washington DC. She said under trump's leadership, the Quad has demonstrated that it is a partnership of action, tackling the region's toughest challenges and drivingopportunitiestoensure a free and open Indo-Pacific. Sources said the Quad »ContinUeD on PaGe 2 explained Show of strength Prime minister narendra modi with the Philippines President ferdinand marcos Jr. in manila, monday. REUtERS summITs In asIa frame IndIa’s sTakes, challenges, Page 10 With the Donald Trump administration posing challenges to bilateral ties with India, Japan and Australia, the Quad grouping has faced headwinds in the last two years. Amid efforts to stabilise ties, the meeting is being framed as a show of strength by the Quad partners, ahead of Trump’s meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin. SayS nBwl aPProval not taken Maharashtra forest dept stops project in which Adani slashed cost by 99% Adani Green Energy: Construction work started after required approvals, awaiting nod from National Board for Wildlife The indian express report published on november 13 Bilkis Bano case: SC suspends life terms of two convicts, grants them bail Chandan haygunde Pune, November 16 the MAhARAShtRA forest Department has ordered work to stop immediately at Adani green energy Limited’s 1,500 MW tarali Pump Storage Project (PSP) in Satara district’s Patantaluka,sayingtheproject started without approval from the national Board for Wildlife (nBWL). theorderwasissuedonnovember 13, the day The Indian Express reported that Adani green energy had sought to sharply revise the cost of its hydropower project to Rs 56.75 crore from Rs 5,675 crore. Responding to questions express news Service New Delhi, November 16 the SUPReMe Court has suspendedthelifesentencesoftwo convicts in the Bilkis Bano case and granted them bail, noting thattheyhadbeenincarcerated for over 17 years and one of them has a “severe handicap”. Bipinchand Kanaiyalal Joshi and Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya, currently lodged in a jail in gujarat, were among the 11menconvictedinthecase.Bilkis Bano, then 21 years old and fivemonthspregnant,wasgangraped and seven of her family members, including her threeyear-old daughter, were killed duringthegujaratriotsin2002. “having heard the parties, suffice it to state that the appellantshavebeenunderincarceration for a period of more than 17 years, and also the fact re- Royals take the gully Britain’s Prince William bowls and Princess kate bats during a game of gully cricket in mumbai on monday, after they arrived on a three-day visit. The royals will attend the earthshot Prize ceremony in the city on Tuesday and meet Prime minister narendra modi in new delhi on Wednesday. SAnKhAdEEP BAnERjEE relaTed rePorT, Page 5 »ContinUeD on PaGe 2 ‘Can’t appeal, nor can I vote’: The Court records say both forgotten voters of Bengal’s SIR aditi raja Vadodara, November 16 BefORe the 2002 gujarat riots, Bipinchand Kanaiyalal Joshi was a neighbour, his housefacingtheonewhereBilkisBanolivedwithherhusband andchildreninRandhikpurvillageofgujarat’sDahoddistrict. Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya had a hotel in the same area. the two men, whose life terms were suspended by the Supreme Court on Monday, wereamongthe11convictedby a Special CBI court in Mumbai in January 2008. the Bombay highCourthadupheldtheconvictions in May 2017. In its judgment, the trial court had recorded an eyewitness account of Modhiya being part of the mob that went on a rampage in Randhikpur on february28,2002,thedayafter the godhra train burning. Prosecution witness Imtiyaz Yusuf ghanchi had told the courtthathehadseenModhiya pelting stones. he had also identified Modhiya’s brother naresh, now »ContinUeD on PaGe 2 States to nilekani task force: give weightage to class 12 board exam scores in neet Gayathri mani New Delhi, November 16 the two ConviCtS were ‘part of mob’, one lived across her house »ContinUeD on PaGe 2 express special Bilkis Bano was raped, seven of her family members were killed in 2002 gujarat riots mainsthatoneoftheappellants has a severe handicap. Certainly, there are issues to be decidedintheappeal,bothonfact and law. In view of the above and considering the issues involved in this appeal, we suspend the sentence and grant bail to the appellants on such termsandconditionsasmaybe imposed by the concerned trial fromTheIndianExpressonthe november 13 order, the company said in a statement, “no component of the tarali Pumped Storage Project falls within any notified Protected Area and no forest land is involved in the project. further, necessary permissions/nOCs relating to land use and statutoryrequirementshavealready been obtained from the competent authorities.” Adani green energy also said it secured environmental Clearance (february 11, 2025) and Consent to establish (April 7, 2025), after which construction began. It said that wildlife clearance proceedings had ravik Bhattacharya & atri mitra Kolkata, November 16 In the never-ending saga of West Bengal’s electoral rolls, they are the forgotten ones. While tribunals continue to hear cases of lakhs of voters markedoutfor“logicaldiscrepancies” during the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) in the state, there are hundreds whose fate remains suspended at the stage of “under adjudication”. Since they didn’t make it to even the tribunal stage, they have been running from pillar topostforthepastyearfiguring out where to go next. Sources put their numbers at over 25,000, spread across Business as usual By EP UNNY Spread across state are hundreds of voters whose cases are still ‘under adjudication’ The sIr exercise in West Bengal started on october 27 last year the minority-dominated constituencies of Murshidabad, Malda, nadia and howrah, with poll officials admitting they were not exactly sure of the total figure. On October 29, the Additional Chief electoral Officer (CeO) of West Bengal wrote to District election Officers over “re-activation of login ID of judicial officers for disposal of caseswheree-signinganddecision (are) pending”. the letter saidthatthestatusofdisposalof pending cases should be submitted by november 3. Md Salauddin Sheikh, 35, a resident of Dhulian in Murshidabad district, is one of those ‘under adjudication’, along »ContinUeD on PaGe 2 west Bengal After deAth of BJP worker, cAll from rAnkS: ‘StoP inducting tmc PeoPle’ PAge 3 PROvIDIng WeIghtAge to Class 12 board exam scores in neet-Ughasemergedasakey proposal from several states cutting across the political divideduring“consultativemeetings” held so far with the nandannilekani-ledtaskforce on exam reforms, The Indian Express has learnt. Sourcestoldthisnewspaper that some of the other proposals discussed in these meetingsincludeofferingmorethan one attempt in a year and adopting a Computer Based test (CBt) mode. “Irrespective of differing opinionsabouttheneetexam and political differences, a majority of states highlighted the importanceofgivingweightage to Class 12 board marks. A majority pointed out that as neet is a common exam, dependence on one test ends up promotingcoachinginstitutesdue to which students are not pre- The nandan nilekani-led panel was announced by the Pm amid the student protests in July paring well for the board exams,” the sources said. Some of the stakeholders were of the view that such dependence has also led to an increase in the number of “dummy schools”. “As soon as students pass the Class 10 exams, they take admission in dummy schools and rely on coaching institutes,” the sources said. government officials said that, except for tamil nadu, all the other southern states supported conducting neet in »ContinUeD on PaGe 2 l amarInder sIngh, TamIl nadu cm VIJay, IndIa Bloc leaders aTTend launch of sonIa memoIr Belonging ‘When you are an outsider, you have this feeling of being watched’ Paromita Chakrabarti & ritu Sarin New Delhi, November 16 sonia gandhi at the book launch in new delhi, monday. AICC If theRe is a recurring theme in Sonia gandhi’s life, it is her struggletobelong.totheItalian city of Orbassano near turin, where she moved with her family from the small Piemontese village of Sangano as a child. to India, where she landed on January 13, 1968, to see for herself the country and the people of the land whose PrimeMinister’ssonshehoped tomarry.toIndianpolitics,that she was loath to join until circumstances pushed her to it. there was, however, one place where Sonia seemed to belong without having to try: besidethemanshehadfallenin love with in Cambridge, Rajiv gandhi. their love, son and Leader of Opposition in Lok SabhaRahulgandhirecounted to a packed audience at the launch of Sonia’s memoir Belonging:AJourneyofLove(harperCollins India) in the Capital on Monday evening, was so instinctive that it shaped his very understandingofwhatafamily should look like. “every meal, there would be Papa and on Papa’s lap, there wouldbeMamma.Ithoughtthis wasanormalthing.AndIwould gotomyfriend’shouseandthey wouldn’t be sitting on each other’s laps and I would ask my friends,whatisgoingon?Whyis national Conference chief fayour mother not sitting on your rooqAbdullah,tMC'sAbhishek father’s lap… this is what we Banerjee, and even BJP leader grew up with,” he said, as the Amarinder Singh. Also present were Congress audience burst out in laughter. Itwasastar-studdedlaunch president Mallikarjun Kharge, with top party leaders and Op- Jairam Ramesh, Mani Shankar position Chief Ministers in at- Aiyar, Sachin Pilot, former tendance. from tamil nadu Prime Minister Manmohan Singh’s wife gurshaChief Minister C Joran Kaur, Sonia’s sephvijay,J&KChief page 1 children Rahul ganMinister Omar Abdhi and Priyanka dullah, Jharkhand gandhi vadra, the Chief Minister hemant Soren, Karnataka Chief latter with husband Robert Minister D K Shivakumar and vadra and children Raihan himachal Pradesh Chief Min- and Miraya. Before Rahul’s speech, in a ister Sukhvinder Singh Sukhu to Samajwadi Party chief Akhi- discussion with harperCollins lesh Yadav and wife Dimple publisher Poulomi Chatterjee, Yadav, nCP (SP)’s Supriya Sule, Sonia spoke of how it was at the anchor Kolkata behest of Rahul and Priyanka that she had finally decided to write of her tumultuous and storied life. “Many people have told me over the years that you mustwriteyourstory.ButIhave alwaysbeenveryreticenttodisclosemyinnerfeelingsandwhat I think about things and people and places,” said Sonia, 79. Belonging spans the arc of her life, from her childhood in Italy to meeting and marrying Rajivgandhitoadjustingtoher life in India and her entry into politics after the assassination of her husband. It is a revealing glimpse into the private world ofawomanwhowouldgoonto become one of India’s most influential political leaders. “Soniagandhi’smemoirisa bold and frank account of her life, written from the heart. When President Abdul Kalam invitedhertobethePrimeMinister, she declined what no leader in the world, male or female, would have done. this wasnotasmallthing.thefactis thathadtheCongresspartycontinued under Sitaram Kesri, it wouldhavecollapsed.theCongresspartycanonlyprosperand grow if a gandhi leads them,” said CM Shivakumar. forgrandsonRaihanvadra, 26, it was, however, not her political life alone that was of interest. “I had read the manuscript while she was writing it. »ContinUeD on PaGe 2
Indian Express Limited is an Indian news media publishing company. It publishes several widely circulated dailies, including The Indian Express and The Financial Express in English, the Loksatta in Marathi and the Jansatta in Hindi.